First things first: we should rename this topic to “The Souls/Borne series.”
Secondly: Bloodborne.
All of you: get the church pick and max it. Strike damage is so overpowered it is not funny. Ebreitas in the chalice dungeons? Easy. Orphan of Kos? What orphan? all I see is a dead corpse. NPCs? Get a church pick guys. Rom, The Vacuous Spider? More like Rom, the dead spider.
Recently I finally got to Queen Yharnam and beat her. Now all I need to do is get the second ending so I can get the platinum trophy.
Ebreitas is my best friend. We like to spar with each other in the Isz dungeons. Also I like it when I get the tileset in the chalice dungeons with the bridges with the cracks in the roof of the dungeon. It gets my hopes up that I can see what areas like Loran and Isz truly look like.
That cut content though… I like that beach boss arena.
Thirdly: Dark Souls 3
I’v actually grown to hate Dark Souls 3 recently. But hate is a bit of a strong word I will admit. Really I should say that it is my least favorite Souls game. My problems boil down to this: Too much fan service, bull**** NPC fights, and questionable game design. Seriously, Nameless and Friede should be in Bloodborne. And what’s with a bonfire spawning after the Dragonslayer armor fight…but then there is a bonfire about 30 feet away? Seriously? And don’t even get me started on Hodrick and Creighton
Dark Souls 3 is in no way a bad game, but it is my least favorite. And it made me realize how much of a flawed masterpiece Dark Souls 2 is. Give DS2 some credit: at least all of the locations are new (baring 2 or 3 special locations). I am going to be honest: I feel DS2 gets too much hate.
Don’t get me wrong though, the game is still flawed. SOTFS was an overly easy rehash, The durability system was bonkers, some bosses were basically filler, and there are questionable level designs (gee, where have we heard that before?).
This is how I rank the games for me personally
- Demon’s Souls (personal bias and it was the first souls game I played)
- Dark Souls/Bloodborne
- Dark Souls/Bloodborne
- Dark Souls 2
- Dark Souls 3
My tastes change over time and It can take me forever to realize something. This ranking may end up changing or it may not. Obviously it doesn’t dictate the quality of the games.